HPWH Insights · Issue 3: Multi-pass stirs the water the heat pump needs cold
Issue 3 · · 8 min read
From AbGarm Energy.
Good morning.
This issue is for engineers choosing how a split heat pump water heater charges its tanks. Our view is that it should run single-pass wherever you have the option.
Multi-pass operation of the primary heater stirs and destratifies the tanks, and only a limited number of HPWHs on the market today can deliver high performance in multi-pass mode. The two lab studies we are sharing do not settle efficiency, so we show both and say where our argument goes further.
Multi-pass stirs the water the heat pump needs cold
A split heat pump water heater keeps its heat pump apart from its storage tanks, and it can charge them in two ways. Single-pass heats cold water to set point in a “single” trip, typically a lift of 70°F to 100°F. It charges the tank from the top.
Multi-pass runs a constant flow through the primary heater and adds heat over “multiple” passes, typically a lift of 10°F at a time. Its high flow stirs the tank’s stratification (the layering of hot water over cold) during the charge time. The charging port of the tank is usually not at the top but in the middle.
Our view is that a split system should run single-pass wherever it can. Multi-pass by design stirs the primary tanks. When the recirculation return port is not selected correctly, the destruction of stratification intensifies.
The failure we worry about is a plant with warm tanks that are not hot enough to serve the building, due to destratification of the tanks.
What the California lab testing showed: In a lab study published on ETCC and supported by California’s local utilities, an 11.3 kW HPWH using R-134a ran both ways. In multi-pass, the tanks were observed to stay “partially stratified” during the 24-hour tests. In our reading, how stratified they stay depends on the tank’s charge and discharge ports.
The report called the partial stratification “somewhat surprising” given the flow through the tanks. Efficiency was higher with a partially stratified tank than a fully mixed one, the report found. The specific conditions it compared, though, were not presented in the report.
The report does not say where the charging flow entered the tank. In its multi-pass tests, the stirring was in what it calls the lower and middle tank. While the heat pump ran, those two mixed: the middle cooled, the lower warmed, and the upper stayed hot.
Once the lower and middle temperatures converged, still cooler than the upper, the middle and upper became more mixed. In our reading, the lower tank staying cooler represents some level of stratification in the primary storage.
Why does that matter? A heat pump draws from the bottom of the tank during charging cycles. The report calls heat pump entering water temperature “the key determinant of system efficiency”.
Of all the configurations studied, multi-pass return-to-primary showed the highest average entering water temperatures. In return-to-primary configurations, the building’s recirculation return flow comes back directly to the primary tanks. That would result in warm water entering the HPWH.
Yet the report found that the multi-pass plant COPs “were still similar to those of other configurations”. Plant COP is our term for the report’s System COP. It covers heat needed for keeping the distribution loop warm as well as hot water draws.
The report defines System COP as “the annual energy demand of the entire water heating system (primary water heating plus temperature maintenance) divided by the energy input required”.
The report explains that the unit’s performance, using R-134a as its refrigerant, “is not significantly impacted by entering water temperature over the range observed”. An HPWH more sensitive to entering water (like units that use CO2 as a working fluid) would see a larger performance drop from a warm, destratified tank. CO2 units also cannot be operated in multi-pass mode.
On a Swiss bench, multi-pass won: A conference paper from Symposium Zukunft Wärme tested a central HPWH whose circulation return flows back into its storage tank, much as in return-to-primary. A return of at least 55°C (131°F) was mandated. Multi-pass reached a daily plant COP of 2.4.
That is up to a fifth higher than the single-pass setups’ 2.1 and 2.0 under similar conditions. The paper cites Switzerland’s hygiene requirements: “according to the standard, the temperature in domestic hot water circulation pipe return must be at least 55 °C and may only fall below this for short periods of time”.
Both supply and return temperatures were higher in the Swiss test setup than in California testing. That makes comparing the results not apples to apples.
One common theme we observed reviewing test results is a large performance loss within the plant boundary. The paper reports unit COPs, which it calls the heat pump performance factor, of 3.0 for both single-pass setups and 3.5 for multi-pass. However, its daily plant COPs, its system performance factor, were 2.1 and 2.0 for single-pass and 2.4 for multi-pass.
Why is the plant COP about a third lower than the unit COP? It is not observed only in this paper; it is a common theme in several studies we follow.
The paper tested a primary HPWH using R290 and computed no stratification metric. However, it does say multi-pass inflow must be introduced “with flow mitigation in order to prevent mixing of the storage water”.
Keeping the primary tanks stratified as much as possible is an important design consideration for central HPWH systems, regardless of single-pass or multi-pass operation of the primary heater.
Both studies point us to one observation. Stratification in the primary storage is one of the key indicators of plant performance.
Single-pass delivers only when the design keeps the tank bottom cold. Multi-pass should be designed to minimize disruption of the hot water at the top of the tank.
The primary tanks should be kept from destratification during charging, and the effects of the recirculation return considered when they are not charging.
Where a split system can run either way, our call is to select single-pass and build the plant configuration around a cold tank bottom. That is when you see the highest level of stratification in the storage tanks.
Run-outs are possible if not sized for the application: The Swiss rig tapped water above 56°C (133°F) for the whole test cycle, which indicates that no run-out was observed.
The California lab’s multi-pass tests of the R-134a unit ran on a lower hot water supply set point, 120°F at the outlet of the master mixing valve, and the report describes no run-outs in them.
The same report’s demand-response tests found otherwise. One multi-pass system there “struggled to maintain the storage setpoint during the morning peak demand period, resulting in a lack of hot water delivery”. In the other, the heat pump “was not able to maintain storage temperatures of 120 degrees”.
Warm, destratified tanks that keep the heat pumps off when supply temperatures drop below desired set points also appear in the reports we read. The cause there is where the recirculation water returns: it mixes the tank without triggering the aquastat to start the primary heater. The next story takes it up.
There is one question this issue does not answer. Is a unitary heat pump water heater, with its heat pump and tank in one package, single-pass or multi-pass?
Where the loop returns can stir the tank
Multi-pass operation of the primary heater is not the only cause that stirs a tank. The recirculation loop keeps hot water moving through the building and brings back lukewarm water. Where should that water re-enter the plant?
Return it high, and the controls lose track: “Across all testing configurations and all equipment,” the ETCC lab report says, returning loop water high in the tank “led to rapid tank destratification and confused the temperature sensors controlling when to turn the heat pumps on.”
A bottom return still stirs: Returning the loop to the bottom of the primary storage tanks “still disrupted the optimal thermal stratification”, the report found. The main effect, it says, was a lower effective primary storage volume, “about 25 percent lower”.
In our reading, the warmer water entering the heat pump also lowers its unit COP. But the bottom return was necessary to make sure the controls operate as they are supposed to. These points show the warm, stirred tank we worry about above, from another cause.
What the research shows
Does the wider research settle the choice? Across the studies we follow, stratification of the primary tanks is the design principle. Multi-pass is generally less stratified than single-pass.
Much of the US guidance and projects we follow ranks single-pass ahead on efficiency. Some of it still finds multi-pass return-to-primary competitive, and the Swiss bench above measured higher performance for multi-pass. The studies differ in refrigerant, set points, recirculation return temperature requirements and the design of tank inlet and outlet ports, so none settles the general case.
They agree on the mechanics: multi-pass moves a high flow at a small temperature rise, so mixing during charging is its main risk. Single-pass needs a cold tank bottom, which mixing by a recirculation return at the bottom of the tank can interrupt.
We did see one report of the supply falling short under multi-pass: the California lab’s demand-response tests above.
THE SPEED READ
At one multifamily retrofit, warm loop water sent to the primary tank overnight destratified the storage and confused the HPWH controllers (ETCC report).
One of two San Francisco senior housing sites spent more time with its supply below set point during some load-shift hours, which in our view calls for more detailed monitoring where load shifting is desired (CalNEXT report).
The report on a packaged CO2 demonstration at two new Menlo Park apartment buildings says low hot water use leaves primary tanks functionally oversized, with reduced stratification and poor load shifting (CalNEXT report).
What to check this week
- Check the plant drawings and the heat pump settings for how each split-system heat pump charges its tanks. The plant piping design should follow the operation setting of the primary heater: do not change one without modifying the other accordingly.
- Check where the recirculation return enters the plant. A return high in a primary tank is the arrangement the ETCC lab report found destratified the tanks and confused the heat pump controls.
- Where multi-pass stays, check that the tank inlet is designed to calm the incoming flow.
- In the design calculation, check the heat pump’s entering water temperature as well as its unit COP. The efficiency of the heat pump alone is not enough for a high-performing plant.
Previously, in issue 2: oversizing the primary heaters is a design flaw, not a margin.
Next, issue 4 takes up temperature maintenance, keeping the building’s loop hot. How to do it is one of the most important design decisions, because high equipment efficiencies can disappear at the system level.
Sources
- ETCC, PG&E and SCE HPWH Laboratory Testing and Software Updates for Multifamily Applications (2024).
- Symposium Zukunft Wärme, Domestic Hot Water Preparation With Heat Pumps in MFH: Single-Pass vs. Multi-Pass Charging (2026).
- ETCC, Field Demonstration Findings for Minimizing Electric Resistance Use in Multifamily and Nonresidential Heat Pump Water Heater Retrofits (2026).
- CalNEXT, Central Heat Pump Water Heating Control Optimization (2025).
- CalNEXT, Packaged Central CO2 Heat Pump Water Heater Multifamily Demonstration (2025).