HPWH Insights · Issue 5: A delayed rule still arrives the day the water heater fails
Issue 5 · · 7 min read
From AbGarm Energy.
Good morning.
On November 4, the Bay Area gave owners more time before its zero-NOx water heater rule applies. It is easy to read that as time to wait. We read it as time to plan, because the rule applies when a water heater is replaced, and most are replaced when they fail.
The Bay Area’s delay is time to plan, not to wait
On November 4, the Bay Area Air District’s Board of Directors voted to amend Rule 9-6, its rule for gas water heaters. The Air District amended it in 2023 to set a zero-NOx standard, one that in practice only electric water heaters such as heat pumps can meet. The new amendments give owners more time.
What moved: The Air District’s release says the amendments “delay the compliance date from January 2027 to January 2028.” That date is for residential water heaters. Multifamily buildings, deed restricted affordable housing and “certain product categories such as hydronic units, specialized high heat uses, and large water heaters” get until January 1, 2033.
Some water heaters are left out. Water heaters “with capacity of 30 gallons or less and mobile home water heaters are not required to comply,” the release says. Exemptions cover low-income owners, properties without room or ventilation for a compliant unit, and electrical limits such as “panels below 100 amps.”
The release defines low-income owners by income, at “less than 80 percent of Area Median Income.” It also includes participants in programs such as Medi-Cal or CalFresh. For an owner near that line, the exemption is worth checking before the old tank fails. From what we heard at the Air District’s workshop, we expect the low-income exemption to be loose at the beginning but tightened as time passes.
When the rule arrives: None of this changes when the rule reaches a building. The standard “applies only when a property owner replaces an existing water heater,” the release says. For most owners, that is the day the old tank fails, the worst day to plan a heat pump.
A building cannot go long without hot water, so a failed heater is replaced fast. A heat pump can need an electrician, a permit or a panel upgrade. Once the compliance date passes, a like-for-like gas tank is no longer an option unless an exemption applies.
The release does allow “temporary installations for emergency situations.” It prints no conditions or time limit for them. An owner who counts on a temporary unit is counting on terms the release does not state.
So what does the delay buy? For a multifamily owner, January 1, 2033 can look far off. The delay moves the deadline, not the day the old water heater fails.
An owner who starts now can line up a panel with room, a space with enough air and a contractor who installs heat pumps. That owner may also be able to use more lucrative incentives and rebates. An owner who waits makes the same choices in a hurry, with higher cost and fewer options to choose from. That holds for homes too, where the date has moved to January 2028.
The delay moves the deadline, not the day the old water heater fails.
Next in the Bay Area: The release gives no date by size of water heater, so we print none. Those dates should be in the regulatory language and staff report linked from the Air District’s Building Appliances page. The release also sends owners there for exemptions and rebates, with no amounts.
In Southern California, South Coast AQMD’s Governing Board voted 7 to 5 on June 6, 2025 not to approve amendments to Rules 1111 and 1121. Those rules cover gas furnaces and water heaters. The agency’s proposed rules page lists no later step, and its 2004 water heater rule remains in effect.
Smart controls saved most where the closet had air
On September 3, the UC Davis Western Cooling Efficiency Center published a report on its website about a field test of smart controls for heat pump water heaters. It covered 17 low-income households at two multifamily properties in Northern California, in San Jose and Woodland. The controls need no new hardware and run through each heater’s manufacturer app.
The system forecasts electricity prices, grid emissions, weather and hot water use. It then heats the tank in advance to avoid the utility’s costliest hours. In the lab, the authors report in an ACEEE paper, it cut utility costs by about 15% against standard factory controls, under ideal forecasts.
The field test measured peak-period energy use, not cost. Woodland’s fell by 31%, a statistically significant result, while San Jose’s fell by 20%, a result that was not. Why did one site save less?
What the closet did: The San Jose units “sat in enclosed interior closets with limited airflow,” the report says. They also served higher hot water demand, so the system leaned more on its less efficient electric resistance backup. The researchers traced the difference to installation conditions.
It is one small test at two sites, and only one result cleared statistical significance. For an owner, the lesson is more about the installation than the app. Where a heat pump goes is best decided before the old water heater fails.
What the research shows
Across the field studies we follow, most water heaters are replaced when the old one fails. At that moment, a heat pump loses to the clock. Any electrical work, permit or panel upgrade pushes the contractor toward a like-for-like gas unit, and most customers follow the contractor’s advice.
Planning ahead helps, but it does not finish the job. In one CalNEXT pilot, a free readiness visit led many owners to reserve a heat pump, yet many still preferred to wait for failure. In the same pilot, when incentive money ran out, reservations largely did not become installs.
A temporary gas loaner, installed while the heat pump is planned, raised one contractor’s conversions in single-family homes, by that contractor’s own account. The Bay Area’s new allowance for temporary installations writes a version of that idea into a rule. We have seen no data yet on how it is used.
THE SPEED READ
Codes and standards
On April 24, 2026, the U.S. Department of Energy said it will delay enforcing the thermal efficiency standards of its 2023 rule for four types of commercial water heating equipment made on or after October 6, 2026 and before October 6, 2027. The four are gas-fired storage water heaters, storage-type instantaneous water heaters, gas-fired instantaneous water heaters and hot water supply boilers. Heat pumps are not named, so an owner should not read it as a delay for them. (DOE)
Programs and incentives
At its August 2026 meeting, the Northwest’s Regional Technical Forum approved workbook v1.1, still under quality review, for its Heat Pump Water Heaters Under 120 Gallons measure, active through 2027, and a research strategy followed a month later; for homes, the forum’s open question is whether units installed without program oversight perform as modeled over their lifetime. (Regional Technical Forum)
Research and field data
On October 26, the Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) published a market assessment of gas heat pumps for commercial water heating, a different technology from the electric heat pump water heaters in this issue; 80% of surveyed market actors who knew the technology had never specified or installed one, so an owner should expect few experienced installers. (NEEA)
On October 8, NEEA posted a modeling study of commercial water heating in hotels, restaurants and multifamily buildings across four Northwest climates, which indicates modulating gas heat pumps are cheapest to run and all-electric heat pump water heaters the most efficient; results vary with electricity-to-gas price ratios, so local rates decide the cost for an owner. (NEEA)
What to check this week
- Ask your contractor how old your water heater is, and what it would take to replace it with a heat pump before it fails.
- If your building is in the Bay Area, check on the Air District’s Building Appliances page whether it falls under the January 2028 date or the January 1, 2033 date, and whether an exemption applies.
- Ask your electrician whether your panel has room for a heat pump water heater, before a failed tank forces the question.
- If you are thinking about switching to a heat pump water heater, think about where it will be installed, to make sure there is enough air around the unit for it to extract heat from.
Previously, in issue 4: how the loop is kept hot decides the system’s efficiency.
To receive the issues that follow, subscribe.
Sources
- Bay Area Air District, Air District Board of Directors adopts water heater rule amendments and delays implementation to January 2028 (2026); also as a web page.
- Bay Area Air District, Rules 9-4 and 9-6 Building Appliances.
- South Coast AQMD, Proposed Amended Rule 1111 and Proposed Amended Rule 1121.
- UC Davis Western Cooling Efficiency Center, Smart Controls Cut Peak Water Heating Costs for Low-Income Households, but Only When the Closet Has Room to Breathe (2026).
- ACEEE, Optimizing Cost and Carbon Footprint: Laboratory Testing of Model Predictive Control for Smart Management of Heat Pump Water Heaters (2024).
- CalNEXT, Residential Electrification Readiness Pilot.
- U.S. Department of Energy, Commercial Water Heater Enforcement Policy (2026).
- Regional Technical Forum, Heat Pump Water Heaters Under 120 Gallons (2026).
- NEEA, Commercial Water Heating Market Assessment: Gas Heat Pump Technology (2026).
- NEEA, Modeling Commercial Water Heating System (2026).