HPWH Insights · Issue 1: Without metering, a water heating plant's faults stay invisible
Issue 1 · · 8 min read
From AbGarm Energy.
Good morning.
Our first issue is about buildings that swap gas water heating for heat pumps. In both of the main cases here, the trouble was reported after the project was finished. In both, it took granular metering to see it. Would your own plant show you the same fault?
Without metering, a water heating plant’s faults stay invisible
This issue starts with the basics of service water heating in buildings. It is the “magic” of opening the shower at 5:00 a.m. on a crisp winter morning. Within seconds, a hot, steamy flow of water is on your skin.
Why is it “magical”, you may ask? Because many things have to fall into place for hot water to come out soon after the tap opens. And nobody really knows how it all works. Design engineers use arbitrary assumptions from decades-old handbooks to estimate a building’s hot water demand and to size its heaters, storage and piping. Installers and contractors work from tribal knowledge and equipment lead times. They swap in different parts and depart from the design documents, to deliver the project with the least delay. Commissioning agents follow an outdated process to commission the system. Operators choose set points and operating modes without clear instructions or training on the system as designed. And yet the magic happens every time we step into the shower and enjoy that cozy morning feeling.
But there are changes on the horizon: the magic may disappear
In the early 20th century, indoor plumbing and running hot water were a luxury of the affluent urban elite. By the mid-20th century, built-in hot water piping had become widespread, and it was required in habitable homes and commercial buildings.
After World War II, housing developments across California grew up around the major gas pipelines, and cheap gas became the fuel for heating water. The New Buildings Institute reports what California’s 2009 Residential Appliance Saturation Survey found. Water heaters burning gas or propane made up 90% of the water heating equipment in California homes.
That is changing. California’s 2025 building energy code, Title 24, expands the use of heat pumps in new homes, for permit applications from January 1, 2026. Regional air quality rules address water heaters directly, with zero-emission and zero-NOx requirements (South Coast AQMD, Bay Area AQMD).
So more and more heat pump water heaters (HPWHs) will be installed in California’s homes and commercial buildings each year. Now is the time for building owners and facility managers to understand what they will soon be dealing with.
Fossil gas is a form of stored energy. A burner releases the fuel’s chemical energy as very high-temperature heat, in a short time. That high heat rate lets a gas water heater work with storage of many sizes, in many plant configurations and applications. It does so without losing much efficiency, or making anyone wait long for hot water at the tap. This abundance of cheap, high-temperature heat has been the force behind the “magic”. It has covered many shortcomings in the design and operation of service water heating in buildings.
Electricity as the energy source for heating water comes with challenges. With electric resistance heating, the expensive electrical infrastructure and the price of electricity make it hard to justify. An HPWH is different. It is a machine that moves heat from a source, such as the surrounding air or a water source, into the service water. It transfers that heat at a lower temperature, and more slowly, than a gas water heater does. To perform like a gas water heater, an HPWH system needs more water storage. The tanks, their set points and the piping configuration make up the plant design. They have a considerable effect on how the hot water system performs. And if the system does not operate as it is supposed to, it is hard to find where the “magic” started to fade.
What is happening in real multifamily installations
HPWHs are advertised as the gold standard for building electrification projects: highly efficient, clean, economical and excellent for load flexibility. But are they really?
How bad it can be: A field evaluation of a central HPWH retrofit, published on ETCC, draws a dire picture. Sierra Vista is an affordable housing community in San Marcos, California, with 12 multifamily buildings of 16 units each. The report describes what happened when it switched from gas water heating to HPWHs.
The initial retrofit was completed in December 2022. The report compares the rise in electricity use on the common-area meters with a model’s estimate. Scaled up from one month to a whole year, it says, the rise came to more than three times the estimate. The bill moved too: the report describes “increases in billing that are close to tenfold”.
Where the electricity went: The report points to the swing tank. A swing tank, a small electric water heater, is added to many HPWH designs to keep the hot water distribution loop hot. In 7 of 11 buildings, the swing tank was the largest contributor to the April 2023 peak water heating load. Its share reached up to 83%. Overreliance on the swing tank, the report concludes, was “a prime contributor to the excessive energy use and costs”.
How the problem was found: A bill alone says only that a building used more. But the project collected circuit breaker loads. A single total shows how much electricity was used, but not which unit used it, or when. More granular monitoring helped the project team uncover the system’s inefficient operation.
The report tries to narrow down the root cause with two explanations. First, it names undersized heat pumps as a possible factor in the higher-than-expected utility bills. Yet, working against that, one heat pump in each building was set to turn off from 4 to 9 p.m., with a few exceptions. That was probably the site’s peak electricity pricing window. Second, it blames overreliance on the swing tank, and the fix was the swing tank’s set point. By the end of April 2023, it says, the contractor had set the swing tank to 110 F. A swing tank set that low can leave the distribution loop cooler than it should be when little water is drawn. That can mean longer waits for hot water at the fixtures, and more dissatisfied residents. It can also raise the risk of bacterial growth in the colder sections of the piping.
Without granular monitoring, inefficiencies can go unnoticed for a long time, and troubleshooting turns into a guessing game.
What about other building types
A data brief published on ETCC makes the same point for other applications.
It presents “preliminary findings” from two buildings retrofit from natural gas water heaters to unitary HPWHs. One is a hotel in Poway, California, and the other a supermarket in Escondido, California, each with two commercial-grade units.
The brief reports a few daily values of the coefficient of performance (COP), the heat delivered per unit of electricity.
The table headings are inconsistent, but a few insights can still be drawn. The unit COP is headed “Plant COP” in one table and “HP COP” in the other two. And what the brief calls “Sys. COP” most probably refers to the plant COP. It includes the units’ electric resistance elements, but does not count distribution losses as a loss.
On six days at the hotel, with different use patterns and ambient temperatures, unit COPs run from 2.29 to 2.86. Plant COPs run from 0.68 to 1.59. At the supermarket, unit COPs run from 1.66 to 2.23, and plant COPs from 1.37 to 1.46. All of them are lower than we would expect from a heat pump water heater.
Among the brief’s findings at the hotel: “There is also a correlation between lower ambient temperatures and runouts in medium and high use days.” At the supermarket, the brief reports unbalanced piping between the primary heaters. Reading the monitoring at both sites, we would add two more possible reasons for low performance: undersized primary heaters, and too little makeup air to the mechanical room. But more information is needed to evaluate the performance properly.
Correct system-level monitoring is essential. A high unit COP does not always mean high system-level performance.
Are low performance cases rare?
Across the studies we follow, they are not. Studies report performance in different ways, but low-performing plants turn up again and again among installed central HPWH systems.
An HPWH’s rated efficiency (COP) is a poor predictor of how the installed plant performs. Among the factors that matter most are the plant’s piping configuration and the right sizing of its primary heaters and storage tanks. So is the way it keeps the distribution loop hot.
Granular metering of electricity use is the first step in evaluating an installed HPWH system.
What to meter: the primary heaters, the supplemental resistance heaters and the recirculation pumps, each on its own.
THE SPEED READ
- At one San Mateo restaurant, a heat pump added ahead of the gas water heater cut gas use by 93 percent on days the restaurant was open, while energy costs rose slightly, about $215 a year. (CalNEXT report)
- At two San Francisco multifamily buildings, central heat pumps that replaced gas cut input energy by 68 to 69 percent from January to October 2023, yet customer utility costs rose 223% and 176%, largely on the per-unit price gap between gas and electricity. (CalNEXT report)
- Lab tests of three consumer heat pump water heaters, for PG&E’s Code Readiness Program, found that an indoor space too small and poorly ventilated starves the unit of the heat it draws from the air. (ETCC report)
What to check this week
- Find out what is metered on your central water heating plant. Ask whether the heat pumps and any electric resistance tank can be read separately, or only as one total.
- Watch how often the heat pumps switch on and off over a day, and whether one unit does most of the running.
- Read the temperature and humidity in the mechanical room, if the heat pump is not ducted outside.
- List the sensors already installed on the plant, and find out whether anyone looks at them regularly.
- If your plant has a swing tank, ask your contractor what it is set to, and why.
Next, in issue 2: how a central heat pump water heating plant is sized, and the methods and tools for doing it.
Sources
- ETCC, Advanced Energy Communities: Centralized Heat Pump Water Heater Retrofit at Sierra Vista (2023).
- ETCC, Code Readiness Commercial Hybrid HPWH Heater Research: Data Brief on Preliminary Findings from Field Monitoring Studies (2026).
- CalNEXT, Restaurant Field Monitoring (2025).
- CalNEXT, Commercial and Multifamily CO2 Heat Pump Water Heater Market Study and Field Demonstration (2023).
- ETCC, Code Readiness: Laboratory Testing of Heat Pump Water Heater Performance: Impact of Airflow and Space Configurations (2023).
- New Buildings Institute, The Building Electrification Technology Roadmap (2021).
- California Energy Commission, 2025 Building Energy Efficiency Standards.
- South Coast AQMD, South Coast AQMD Approves Rule to Accelerate the Transition to Zero-Emission for Building Water Heaters.
- Bay Area AQMD, Regulation 9 Rule 6: Nitrogen Oxides Emissions from Natural Gas-Fired Water Heaters.